Interior Decorating Book Reviews: Compact Living

 
Reviews of Compact Living

    - Publication information
    - Buy this book

Review #1: Lots of structural solutions
Review #2: read ALL of the reviews
Review #3: Title should be "Compact living... on a limitless renovation budget."





Review #1

Lots of structural solutions

Many cool examples of small homes with sound advice on how to maximize your space--if you can make structural adjustments to your home. Almost all the rooms feature new contemporary furnishings and therefore might be better suited for people with a chunk of change to spend. Although I like this book to some extent it doesn't fit my needs as a renter.




Review #2

read ALL of the reviews

Whether they found the book helpful or not, what the other reviewers have to say is true. Graining's remedies for compact living are expensive, professionally designed, and professionally installed . The materials are cutting-edge and the taste is ultra-modern.
But there are some truly innovative solutions for living in a small space (which may inspire you to get creative about your own space). And some basic and practical ideas are sprinkled throughout.

What makes this a 5 star book for me, however, is that it includes something the others don't: FLOORPLANS. There are illustrations of the entire layout, including furniture placement and photos of every room in the house. While these apartments may not resemble anything like your own home, getting to see the individual rooms and how they fit together in the whole space to form a cohesive design IS useful. I've seen some of the photos in this book in other design books (as an isolated room, photographed from one angle). Being able to see how they work with the rest of the space and flow with adjoining rooms is immeasurably helpful.




Review #3

Title should be "Compact living... on a limitless renovation budget."

Title should be "Compact living... on a limitless renovation budget."

Everything is designer showroom-perfect on these pages, like an Ikea or Pottery Barn or Crate and Barrel catalog.

However the spaces lack human reality, such as quirky collections or individualized space needs or child friendly design. You don't even meet the inhabitants.

Yes, invest in built in cabinets and fold away stair cases if you own and have the money. Again, these options are unattainable for many struggling to pay the mortgage or are renting.

A much better book is Bartolucci's "1000 sqft or less." That features real people with real budgets.

I wanted real advice, not catalog advertisements for perfect unattainable ideal design. I was disappointed. But perhaps idealism and extravagance, not realism and cash poor budgets are what most readers want... Hence the popularity of ARchitectural Digest, and why I am so turned off by such mags.




Check for more reviews on Amazon.com


Similar Products:



Compact Living

by Jane Graining

Format: Hardcover
Publication Date: 1999-09
Publisher: Soma Books
ISBN: 1579590268

    List Price: $28.00
Price: $10.20

Buy from Amazon.com
Buy from Amazon.ca
Buy from Amazon.co.uk

Compact Living Reviews


book-reviews.info home


Book-Reviews.info





Search for more book reviews:




Browse for Book Reviews:



Page last updated on: 21 Mar 2010